Lincoln Wheat Penny

The Lincoln Wheat Penny Coin reached $9.1M Value

by

Lincoln Wheat Penny : In the rarefied air of ultra-high-end numismatics, where gold double eagles and pattern coins typically reign supreme, a small copper disc has stunned the collecting world by shattering every conceivable record for American small cents.

Last month, in the climate-controlled confines of a private auction room in Boston, a 1943-S copper Lincoln wheat penny—one of the rarest and most mythologized coins in American numismatic history—changed hands for an astonishing $9.1 million, establishing it as not merely the most valuable penny ever sold but one of the most valuable coins of any denomination in collecting history.

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Penny That Shouldn’t Exist

To understand the astronomical value of this particular penny requires diving into one of numismatics’ most fascinating chapters. During World War II, copper was classified as a strategic war material, essential for producing ammunition and other military supplies.

In response to conservation efforts, the U.S. Mint transitioned from using copper to zinc-coated steel for penny production throughout 1943.

At least, that was the plan.

Through what collectors refer to as a “mint error of historic proportion,” a minuscule number of copper planchets (the metal discs that become coins) from 1942 evidently remained in the presses or hoppers and were struck with 1943 dies.

These copper 1943 pennies—produced at Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco mints—became instant rarities, with the San Francisco examples being the scarcest of all.

“We believe fewer than six genuine 1943-S copper cents exist,” explains Margaret Thornhill, curator of American coinage at the Smithsonian Institution. “Each represents a fascinating moment when industrial processes designed for wartime efficiency failed in a small but significant way.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Discovery That Began in a Schoolboy’s Lunch Money

The particular coin that commanded this record-shattering price has a provenance as remarkable as its composition. Its journey began in 1957 when 14-year-old Michael Wilkinson of Burlingame, California, noticed something unusual about one of the pennies he’d received as change from his school cafeteria.

“Dad always told me that story,” recalls James Wilkinson, Michael’s son and the coin’s most recent seller. “He was saving wheat pennies like many kids did back then, but he noticed this one was copper, not steel, and the date was 1943. He’d read enough coin books to know that was unusual.”

The young collector kept the coin as his “special find” but never had it authenticated during his lifetime. After graduating from Stanford and building a successful engineering career, Michael occasionally showed the penny to friends but declined offers from local coin dealers who expressed skepticism about its authenticity.

“He wasn’t particularly interested in selling it—it was just this cool thing he’d found when he was a kid,” James explains. “It wasn’t until after he passed away in 2021 that we discovered it in a small envelope marked ‘My lucky penny’ in his desk drawer.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Authentication That Stunned Experts

When James Wilkinson brought the penny to Heritage Auctions for assessment in early 2023, senior numismatist Robert Matthews initially approached it with the standard skepticism that greets all purported 1943 copper cent discoveries.

“Ninety-nine percent of the ‘copper 1943 pennies’ we see are either altered dates from 1945 or 1948 pennies, or copper-plated steel cents,” Matthews explains. “We receive hundreds of inquiries every year, and almost none are genuine.”

This coin, however, was different. Initial tests confirmed it wasn’t magnetic (ruling out a copper-plated steel cent), and microscopic examination showed no evidence of date alteration. Metallurgical analysis revealed the composition matched the 95% copper, 5% tin and zinc alloy used in 1942 pennies.

The final verification came through die-marker analysis—microscopic points on the coin’s surface that match known authentic examples—which confirmed this was indeed struck from genuine 1943-S dies. The coin was eventually certified and graded MS-64 Red by Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), indicating a near-gem uncirculated condition with more than 90% of its original mint luster intact.

“When we confirmed it was genuine, there was this momentary silence in the authentication room,” Matthews recalls. “We were looking at a coin that represented a perfect numismatic storm—extreme rarity, historical significance, superb condition, and a remarkable provenance story. Those factors almost never align.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Auction That Made History

The decision to sell wasn’t immediate for the Wilkinson family. For several months following authentication, they considered museum donation options and private sale opportunities. Ultimately, the potential for establishing a charitable foundation with the proceeds motivated them to consign the penny to auction.

The sale was conducted on April 18, 2025, through a sealed-bid process limited to pre-qualified collectors. When the winning bid of $9.1 million was announced, it represented a price more than double the previous record for any small cent and placed the humble penny in the same valuation category as legendary coins like the 1804 Silver Dollar and the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel.

The buyer, who chose to remain anonymous, released a brief statement through the auction house: “This coin represents American ingenuity, historical circumstance, and extraordinary chance—the very elements that make numismatics the most fascinating of collecting pursuits. I’m honored to be its temporary steward.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny Beyond the Record: Understanding Wheat Penny Values

While most Americans won’t discover a multi-million dollar rarity in their change jar, the record-breaking sale has sparked renewed interest in wheat pennies, which were minted from 1909 through 1958 and feature two wheat stalks on the reverse side.

“We’ve seen a 300% increase in wheat cent submissions for grading in the weeks following this sale,” notes Patricia Lancaster of Numismatic Guaranty Corporation. “Most aren’t valuable, but there are certainly treasures still waiting to be discovered.”

For collectors hoping to identify potentially valuable specimens, experts highlight these key dates:

  • 1909-S VDB: The first-year issue with designer Victor David Brenner’s initials and the San Francisco mint mark, with only 484,000 produced. Even in circulated condition, these regularly bring $750-$2,000.
  • 1914-D: With a low mintage of 1.2 million and poor initial preservation, these command $250-$1,500 depending on condition.
  • 1922 Plain: A die error resulted in some 1922-D cents with the mint mark missing entirely, creating a sought-after variety worth $500-$2,000.
  • 1931-S: The Great Depression reduced mintage to just 866,000, making these worth $100-$400 in average circulated condition.

While genuine 1943 copper cents remain the “holy grail” of wheat penny collecting, their extreme rarity means most collectors will never encounter one. More accessible are their counterparts—1944 steel cents, created when steel planchets from 1943 were accidentally used the following year. These bring $75,000-$125,000 depending on condition.

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Science Behind the Authentication

What makes the verification of a true 1943 copper cent so challenging is the sophistication required to distinguish genuine examples from alterations. Modern authentication combines traditional numismatic expertise with advanced scientific techniques.

“We now employ X-ray fluorescence spectrometry to analyze metal composition without damaging the coin,” explains Dr. Helena Reynolds, materials scientist and numismatic consultant. “This allows us to determine precise metal content percentages and detect copper plating over steel.”

Other authentication techniques include:
  • Specific gravity testing: Genuine copper cents have different density than steel cents
  • High-resolution microscopy: Reveals tooling marks from altered dates
  • Die variety analysis: Confirms the dies used match known genuine examples
  • Magnetic susceptibility measurement: Steel is magnetic; copper is not

“What made the Wilkinson specimen particularly convincing was that it passed every test we could throw at it,” Reynolds notes. “Many altered coins might pass one or two tests, but genuine examples pass them all.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Historical Significance

Beyond its value to collectors, the 1943 copper cent represents a unique intersection of American wartime history and numismatic chance. The country’s mobilization for World War II affected everything from consumer goods to monetary metals, and these rare pennies stand as tangible evidence of that transitional period.

“These coins speak to a time when every resource, down to the copper in our smallest denomination, was considered vital to the war effort,” explains Dr. Malcolm Harrison, historian specializing in American home front studies. “They’re accidental artifacts that connect us directly to that moment of national sacrifice and industrial transformation.”

The San Francisco Mint, where the record-breaking penny was struck, held particular significance during this period. Located in a critical West Coast port city, it operated at full capacity supporting wartime finance while many of its experienced personnel were serving in the armed forces.

“The wonder isn’t that a few copper planchets slipped through,” Harrison notes, “but that more errors didn’t occur given the pressure these facilities were under with reduced staff and increased production demands.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Investment Perspective

The extraordinary sale has naturally raised questions about coins as investment vehicles. Financial advisors caution that while certain rare coins have appreciated dramatically, the broader numismatic market shows more modest returns.

“This sale represents the absolute pinnacle of the market,” explains financial analyst Katherine Westin, who specializes in alternative investments. “It’s like using a Picasso sale to represent the art market or a Honus Wagner card to represent sports memorabilia. These are outliers that make headlines precisely because they’re exceptional.”

Nevertheless, Westin acknowledges that carefully selected numismatic rarities have shown strong performance compared to traditional investments.

“Blue-chip coins with established rarity and historical significance have appreciated at approximately 8-12% annually over the past five decades. The key is expertise—understanding population reports, grading standards, and authenticity issues.”

For average collectors, she recommends focusing on education before investment. “Buy the book before you buy the coin” remains the most repeated advice in numismatics.

Lincoln Wheat Penny Looking Forward: Will the Record Stand?

Numismatic historians are divided on whether the $9.1 million record will stand long-term. Some point to other legendary American rarities that could potentially command higher prices if they were to come to market.

“There are coins like the 1804 dollar, where we know of only 15 examples, or the 1913 Liberty nickel with just five known,” points out auction historian Thomas Reynolds. “These have traditionally been considered the pinnacle of American numismatics and could potentially exceed this price.”

Others believe the unique historical narrative and extreme rarity of the 1943 copper cents give them special appeal that transcends traditional collecting hierarchies.

“What makes the ’43 copper cent so compelling is that everyone can relate to it,” explains Deborah Silverman, author of several books on coin collecting psychology. “We’ve all handled pennies. The idea that something so ordinary could be so extraordinary creates a powerful mystique that appeals beyond traditional collector circles.”

Lincoln Wheat Penny The Legacy of a Lunch Money Discovery

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of this record-breaking sale is how it reinforces the democratic nature of coin collecting. Unlike many high-value collectibles sequestered in vaults for generations, this penny circulated freely until a young boy’s curiosity preserved it.

“Dad never considered himself a serious collector,” James Wilkinson reflects. “He just noticed something unusual and saved it. There’s a beautiful simplicity to that—no sophisticated knowledge, no massive investment, just curiosity and appreciation for something different.”

As the new owner builds a specialized display for this numismatic treasure, millions of Americans will undoubtedly check their own cents with renewed interest. And while few will find a multi-million dollar rarity, the hunt itself connects them to a tradition as old as coinage itself—the human fascination with the stories our money tells about us.

In the end, perhaps that’s the true value of the humble Lincoln cent that now commands the price of a mansion—not just its copper composition or stunning rarity, but its power to remind us that history sometimes hides in plain sight, waiting for an observant eye to recognize its significance.

Also Read This-

Leave a Comment